PLAY CITY HOME Take Action Campaigns Projects People Blog About
 
join

When Things Go Too Far: Caster Semenya Suicide Watch

Posted by:TaraLConley on September 16, 2009 at 09:56 AM

The Associated Press is reporting that 18-year-old South African runner, Caster Semenya is on suicide watch after recent tests revealed (in front of the entire world no less) that she is intersex.

A few weeks ago I wrote about Caster Semenya and the politics of gender identification in sports

At the time of posting, Semenya's test results were still unknown.  I posed a hypothetical and futuristic scenario about gender neutral Olympics where all is well with athletes competing in non sex-segregated sporting events. A utopic scenario, I admit.

Now it all seems to have taken a turn for the worst.  According to the AP report "officials as saying that psychologists are caring [for] the 18-year-old round-the-clock after it was claimed tests had proved she was a hermaphrodite."

South African lawmaker Butana Komphela, said: "[Semenya] is like a raped person. She is afraid of herself and does not want anyone near her. If she commits suicide, it will be on all our heads. The best we can do is protect her and look out for her during this trying time."

The mere fact that it's gotten to the point that Semenya is reportedly on suicide watch indicates that we've all failed; sports officials, consumers, and media.  We've done what we always do; react like vultures when consuming someone else's personal story and personal tragedy. Probing so deeply into this woman's life while taking away her voice in the process illustrates our failure as a global society to care for our own; our daughter. 

I'm not being hyperbolic either.  Within the past few weeks, I've encounter some disturbing commentary on popular blog sites and so-called "news sources" (for obvious reasons, I won't like back to these sites).  Folks calling Semenya out of her name, insisting she's a 'freak of nature.' Otherizing her so much to the point that somewhere along the line she felt it necessary to perform her gender on a magazine cover, just to prove to us - the voyeurs - that she is who she identifies as. 



The damage has been done.  Semenya is a victim of modern-day voyeurism. Without context and without care, we, the folks, raped her by violating her personhood. By casting a chastising eye on her, we've denied her the right have the quality of life she deserves.  Having an open and fair-minded discussion about gender identity in sports is fair game, (and I'm sure the debate will only explode from this point on) but exploiting a person's story as a way to essentially mask our own fears of the Other is (what Tweeters would refer to as) an #epic fail.

Caster Semenya's story also indicates another important issue concerning women of color and mental health.  I recently wrote about this very topic highlighting yet another woman of color apparently suffering from mental illness while in the virtual world spot light.

Should sports and government officials have handled Semenya's situation differently? Absolutely.  Especially when considering that her personal medical tests results were revealed to the entire world.  She has nothing, I repeat, nothing, to prove to you or me.

Should bloggers and commenters have self-censored themselves before posting derogatory and misleading commentary about Semenya, intersexuality, and hermaphroditsm? Without a doubt.

Sadly, none of the above occurred, and because of these blunders of epic proportions a young 18-year-old woman reportedly sits contemplating her life's demise, despite being one of the most promising track & field athletes of our time.

Enough is really enough. Even though so much damage has already been done, it would behoove us as a collective to support our daughter during this time with prayers, meditations, reflective blog posts, supportive Twitter/Facebook updates; whatever suites your fancy. We've got some serious redeeming to do.

Caster Semenya, you have my love and support.

Tara

(AP Photo/Markus Schreiber)

**UPDATE: Former track & field Olympian, Carl Lewis, speaks out, stating that ASA officials are to blame for how the Semenya story has been playing out around the world.

"It's your fault." Lewis goes on to say that athletics officials should have protected Caster Semenya from the controversy: "She is your athlete in your country and you didn't deal with this before. To put it out in front of the world like that, I am very disappointed in them because I feel that it is unfair to her."

 



Leave a Comment

To leave a comment you must have a YouthNoise account.
Username Need help with your password? Password

Comments (8)

Displaying 1 - 8
    Report Inappropriate Content! By trinachi September 20, 2009 at 07:46 AM
It's so sad that a rigid (and clearly unrealistic) vision of gender caused so much suffering for Semenya. Her personal information should not have been so readily placed on public display, especially given our social/political climate that deals with gender in such a harsh and unforgiving manner. Like Anne Marie said, I hope that this unfortunate situation will help our culture to reassess our definition of gender. Perhaps a high-profile, successful intersex athlete will help other intersex people to feel more comfortable with their bodies and/or gender. Or perhaps the story will encourage traditionally gendered, non-intersex individuals to adopt a more inclusive view of gender. Perhaps. Regardless, I really wish that Semenya didn't have to be the poster child for intersex issues, without her consent.

    Report Inappropriate Content! By gilliebean September 17, 2009 at 01:53 PM
This makes me so angry for her. I completely agree that bloggers and commenters should have checked themselves before circling like vultures around the hot new piece of gossip. Did they even think that maybe she's a person who deserves respect and compassion, not just a "freak of nature" they should exploit for pageviews? Semenya, sending much love and support your way.

    Report Inappropriate Content! By Anne Marie Herwig September 17, 2009 at 10:05 AM
Gender lies on a spectrum- it is unfortunate that more people don't see it that way. Hopefully this will open up dialogue and help us have more compassion for our differences in the future

    Report Inappropriate Content! By OakleyAM September 16, 2009 at 03:39 PM
I can only hope that Semenya is able to recover from this psychological trauma and become and even stronger person; maybe one who could advocate for intersex athletes in the future. If nothing else, perhaps more hermaphrodite athletes and people alike will be able come out and know they aren't alone. I wish there was a way to write letters to Semenya of support, if they would ever make it to her.

    Report Inappropriate Content! By Lauren Hauser September 16, 2009 at 11:27 AM
This is a really powerful story that I agree, we should think about as a society. It's just so troubling to think that so many people feel the need to comment, degrade, and expose issues like this as 'freak of nature.' Does it REALLY make your life better to degrade people that are different then us?
Your piece is well written Tara and hopefully it encourages others to support, not criticize Semenya in a difficult time in her life. Thanks for writing this!

    Report Inappropriate Content! By theresaverzosa September 16, 2009 at 11:25 AM
disturbing and sad...

    Report Inappropriate Content! By jameshodges September 16, 2009 at 10:27 AM
I still hold out hope that the suicide watch is simply a matter of whacked out procedure, and Caster is doing all right... but regardless, my thoughts are with her today.

I think a lot of important dialogues are about to open up, but it shouldn't have come to this.

    Report Inappropriate Content! By TaraLConley September 16, 2009 at 11:13 AM
I hope you're right, James. Though, I still believe so much damage has been done that it's beyond peril. The best we can all do is support this young female athlete no matter what.

facebook myspace twitter youtube flickr
partners
© 2007 YouthNoise. All rights reserved. Search powered by google